|Full Name||Jonathan Crane|
University Professor (Formerly) Psychologist (Formerly)
Psychatrist at Arkaham Asylum (Formerly)
|Base of Operations||Blackgate, Arkham Asylum, Gotham City|
|Affiliations||Joker (formerly) |
Arkham Knight (formerly)
Simon Stagg (formerly)
|Voice Actor||Dino Andrade (Arkham Asylum) John Noble (Arkham Knight)|
|First Appearance||World's Finest Comics #3 (September 1941)|
Taunted and bullied in his youth, Jonathan Crane vowed to overcome his fears through the study of psychology and biochemistry on phobias and the nature of fear. Kicked out of the university he taught at for experimenting on human subjects, Crane adopted the identity of the Scarecrow, and armed himself with a specialized fear-inducing gas that made a person's deepest phobia become frighteningly real. Scarecrow's ongoing reign of terror made him one of Batman's most recurring and psychologically dangerous foes. Crane was brutally mauled by the mutated criminal, Killer Croc, and exacted his revenge on Batman and Gotham City with his allies, the mysterious Arkham Knight and the former assassin, Deathstroke.
He served as the tertiary antagonist of Arkham Asylum, and the main antagonist of Arkham Knight.
Life at Blackgate PrisonEdit
Jonathan Crane became a professor of psychology and psychiatry to overcome his fears of being teased by his classmates for his obsession with his studies. He was an employee at Blackgate Prison to research on fear and nightmares. Crane then made a gas that induced fear in his patients. Crane ran his tests on the criminals in the prison to improve his toxin.
The Birth of ScarecrowEdit
Years later, Crane became the Scarecrow, one of Gotham's emerging super villains, who specialized in inflicting fear on others with his self designed toxin known as Fear Gas.
With each defeat he dealt to him by Batman, Crane usually suffered being exposed to his own Fear Toxin; this had an unintended side-effect on his self-preservation cortex (the part of the brain that controls the survival instinct/fear). Crane was gradually beginning to lose his own sense of fear, increasing the instability of his mind; however, due to Batman being what he saw when infected by Fear Toxin, Crane retained a fear of bats no matter how much his own immunity increased.
Before Arkham Asylum IncidentEditEven though Scarecrow was returned to Arkham, he continued his plans from a secret loft that was hidden at the Intensive Treatment Center, and plotted his next move with some stolen blueprints of the Asylum. In secret, Scarecrow managed to hide three canisters worth of his Fear Toxin in Arkham West; unknown to him, the Riddler would discover the cache and make it one of his riddles for Batman. Scarecrow was later incarcerated at Arkham Asylum as the Suicide Squad arrived. Crane managed to escape when the Joker let everyone out of their cells, allowing Crane to infect officers with Fear Toxin and escape. Though he was eventually recaptured.
While incarcerated, Crane caused at least two of his doctor's, Dr. Murphy and Dr. Combs to suffer Fear Toxin induced breakdowns and was eventually referred to Dr. Stephen Kellerman three weeks later. Despite Kellerman's attempts to treat him, Crane acted as though he were conducting the sessions, even dictated notes, and was simply patronizing the other doctor. Crane toyed with Kellerman during each session, shared his philosophy on fear as the driving force behind the human condition, and even used everyday examples from the therapist's supposedly fulfilling life as evidence.
These meetings rattled Kellerman, who came to believe that Crane was simply sadistic rather than insane (with there not being much difference). Crane's mind games were actually having even more of an effect on Kellerman due to the Fear Toxin chemicals he had incorporated into his cologne, and was also exposed to the guards who brought him to each session. This was part of a plan to further Scarecrow's research, who rigged the Medical Facility's air conditioning system to flood the building with the rest of his latest Fear Toxin formula. Everyone exposed to both components began to hallucinate their worst nightmares.
Before Crane could continue, Batman crashed into the room. Kellerman had realized what his patient was up to, and provided the Dark Knight with a sample of the toxin to create an antidote, which he gave to Aaron Cash to disperse through the rigged air conditioning system. Scarecrow was amazed that Batman seemed to be unaffected by the gas, then gleeful when he implied that he was being affected as much as anyone else. Despite his pleas to learn what kind of vision his nemesis had seen, Crane was defeated, arrested, and returned to his cell, and lost once again to the Dark Knight's willpower.
Arkham Asylum Incident Edit
Scarecrow was one of the Arkham inmates on the Joker's "party list", and who was released during the Clown Prince of Crime's takeover of Arkham Island, both to distract Batman and for the Joker's general amusement. Crane made use of his secret stash of Fear Toxin, intending to break Batman this time. It's suggested by a fake patient session the Joker had with Batman, that Crane had been studying Batman with him; both were confused as to why Batman hadn't snapped, and come over to their side yet.
Batman tracked a kidnapped Commissioner Gordon to the island's Medical Facility. After he rescued several captive medical staff, Batman took out a raiding party of thugs before he took the elevator to the lower levels to follow Gordon's forensic trail of tobacco. The Joker taunted Batman through the Asylum's CCTV system, and considered to just release the elevator from its cables, but only as a joke. As Batman made his way into the basement levels, he began coughing on a colorless gas being remotely pumped into the elevator. Joker also previously mentioned Crane as one of two "old friends" coming to the party - "one will be absolutely terrified if you leave without saying hello."Scarecrow had already gone to work with torturing new victims for research data; having injected them with his Fear Toxin, he watched as they all died of heart-attacks before fleeing into another part of the building. Noting that the "good doctor" had started work early, Joker laughed that Batman would be buzzed through for his "appointment" when Scarecrow was ready, going on to ask what the Dark Knight feared most.Batman used the vents to bypass the doors, finding Commissoner Gordon calling for help through one of the grates. Moments, later Batman emerged from the vents to find the corpse of his dear friend. His mind reeling from one of his greatest fears, Batman attempted to hunt Scarecrow down, only to find himself in the Morgue, where he was confronted by the animated corpses of his parents and a twisted obstacle course that was overseen by a giant, omnipotent Scarecrow. After he realized that he was experiencing a Fear Toxin hallucination, Batman overcame the delusion by avoiding the delusional Scarecrow's fiery gaze, used a Bat-Signal as a symbol of his willpower, and shined its light directly into Scarecrow.
Over the course of the night, Batman uncovered the mystery of the Titan Formula and investigated the Arkham Mansion to find either Dr. Penelope Young or to destroy her notes. He managed the latter, but the Joker wasn't outdone yet, and sent Victor Zsasz after Dr. Young. Batman raced off to find her, but was gassed by Scarecrow again. This trapped Batman in a hallucination of the night that his parents were murdered as his nine-year-old self, and walked down a seemingly never-ending hall that turned into Crime Alley. He overcame this part of the delusion by remembering the kind words of a younger Jim Gordon, returned to his adult state, used all his skills to once again avoid the Scarecrow's gaze, and illuminated him with the Bat-Signal. Batman managed to free himself a second time, discovering that he had gotten himself trapped inside the belfry. This also made him too late to prevent Zsasz from taking Dr. Young hostage in the Warden's Office.
As the night wore on, Batman learned from Poison Ivy of a plant spore in the Asylum's sewer system that would help him concoct an antidote to the Titan Formula and returned to the Intensive Treatment Center to retrieve it from Killer Croc's Lair. As Batman made his way to the elevators, he began coughing on the Fear Toxin again and experienced a strange kind of vertigo: his vision was filled with static to the distorted sound of the Joker's laughter. At this point, Batman began reliving the earlier events of the night, but in Joker's place.The Joker arrived at Arkham in the Batmobile, and took Batman to the Intensive Treatment Center. Batman ranted and raved, insisted that he hadn't killed that family, and demanded to be cut free. He resisted Dr. Crane's attempts to examine him, who then declared him a lost cause and left him to the Joker's mercy. The Joker leveled his gun at Batman's head and fired at point-blank range.
After he realized that he was suffering yet another Fear Toxin hallucination, Batman climbed out of his own grave and made his way past the cells that were full of other insane Batmen to find the Bat-Signal. Now being gripped by Batman, Scarecrow decides to inject him with more toxin, to see what demons he has left to face. Two Titan henchmen and several regular ones attacked Batman as Scarecrow watched. Batman prevailed yet again, and defeated as many skeletal warriors as needed to strike Scarecrow with the three Bat-Signals.
Scarecrow was left shocked by these turn of events, giving Batman another quick jab of toxin, buying himself time to flee to the elevator with a pouch full of his toxin; he wonders why Batman can't admit that the relationship between him and the super criminals is symbiotic. Crane rode the elevator all the way down to the lowest level, to reach the sewers; he didn't know that the sewer system served as the lair of Killer Croc. Joker's goons locked the way back up behind him, hoping Crane would get eaten by Croc, as they find him creepy; however, Batman pummeled them and unlocked the path.
As Batman examined a Titan-mutated plant, Scarecrow warned him to stay away, or he would drop the bag of Fear Toxin into the underground river; the cavern would fill with all Batman's worst nightmares. Worse, the Gotham water supply would be contaminated for over 100 years due to the potency. Before Scarecrow could make good on his threat, Killer Croc burst from the water and grabbed Crane, having mistaken him for a guard or stray inmate. Scarecrow lost his grip on the Fear Toxin, letting drop harmlessly to the ground.
About to be bitten into by Croc, Scarecrow was saved by Batman, who hurled a Batarang at Croc's electrified restraining collar, which stunned the monster. Unfortunately, Croc refused to release Scarecrow, dragging the screaming madman into the water with him. Scarecrow then was badly mauled by Croc, who immediately let him go; tracking down and eating Batman was top priority on Croc's list.
After Arkham Asylum Incident Edit
Though terribly injured, Crane managed to sneak into Gotham without drawing attention. He managed to gain access to medical attention, receiving a leg brace for his left leg as Croc's strong grip had broken it. His face had been severely disfigured thanks to Killer Croc, now missing some of his teeth and his right eye becoming blinded, along with chunks of his nose gone as well, how severe his facial injuries were are unknown, as rumors around Gotham during his attack implied that he either wore a mask to hide them or that his 'mask' was actually his face. Though it his pain was his own fault for being careless, Scarecrow instead blamed Batman for his injuries; feeling that only making Batman afraid wasn't enough anymore, Crane now plotted to unmask and mentally break him on live television, to show Gotham that their protector was nothing more than a mere man.To this end Crane managed to find a hideout in Chinatown, where he set up a lab behind the storeroom of Mr. Chen's toy factory; he also gained control of the top floor of another building, where he built a gassing chamber with a two-way monitor for communications. He also brokered with the Falcone family, obtaining a boat next to their shipping yard; the hull's contents included crates Crane specifically requested be filled with insects with neuro-toxins. With these hideouts, and possibly others, Crane bided his time as he continued to experiment in order to find the ultimate Fear Toxin to break the Batman once and for all.
As the months passed by, Crane remained hidden from Gotham, leading most of the GCPD to believe that Croc had killed him; however Batman persisted in trying to find Crane, or some evidence of where his corpse was. When Old Gotham was later converted into the super prison known as Arkham City, Crane saw a good chance to obtain an abundant amount of test subjects for his research as the Industrial District now served as Joker's territory. Among the many tests subjects was one of the Joker's most devoted followers, Roach; Crane could see the goon was fighting off any visible signs of fear, deciding to explain about his latest batch of toxin and his desire to prevent another failure like the one back at Arkham Asylum from happening again.
Crane appeared to have been in contact with both the Identity Thief and the Riddler, as several containers of his Fear Gas were found in the thief's hideout and in one of the rooms in which Riddler held a challenge for Batman. If true, that would explain how Crane's old mask became one of the riddles that Nygma had prepared for the Dark Knight; unless it was just a copy to remind Batman that he hadn't found Crane yet. Batman also found Crane's hideout, and Roach, who had a panic attack the moment Batman examined him. Crane was nowhere to be found, possibly having found a way to enter and leave Arkham City unknown to everyone else, as no-one but Black Mask (who used explosives) had managed to escape the prison.
The Joker appeared to know he was alive, as he suggested his Fear Toxin as being the reason Batman was hallucinating. If true, this would explain the relative ease with which Scarecrow could get victims to experiment on with his Fear Toxin, as Joker was sadistic and enjoyed causing others misery; the Clown Prince of Crime cared little for his minions, and disposed of them when they weren't useful
Further, it appeared that Crane had his own agents in Arkham City; during Protocol 10, many dead prisoners in orange skeleton/scarecrow outfits could be found. It's possible they worked for the other villains' crews undercover, just like the Riddler's, or had simply kept out of trouble and gathered information for Crane.
Crane later sent three hidden radio frequencies on the Cryptographic Sequencer to Batman. Each was a numeric code which, once translated, read: "I will return Batman!" "You will pay for what you have done to me!" and "Fear will tear Gotham to shreds!" Following the closing of Arkham City, Scarecrow listened in about the explosion at Arkham, which many mistakenly believed claimed Batman's life, commenting on how stupid the police are as guns do not scare criminals and empower even the weaker thugs. He continued to play the message over and over, hoping Batman would learn of his impending return.
Before Arkham Knight Incident Edit
Penguin later employed Mister Hammer and Captain Sickle to track down Scarecrow, wanting him to join his group to bring order back to Gotham. Possibly leaking information deliberately, Crane managed to lure them into his hideout in Chinatown, where they found a scarecrow dressed like Batman strung to the ceiling. Sickle made the poor choice of smashing the bottles in Crane's lab, sending both brothers into a hallucination of their father attempting to kill them. Crane tortured them for days, perhaps using their strong wills and bodies to test how lethal his toxin had become. He ended up sewing them back together, a wish the twins had, and stuffing straw into Sickle's mouth; he sent them back to Penguin with a message.
Needing better resources for his research, Crane entered a partnership with Simon Stagg. After months of extensive research, Crane ended up up creating a strain of Fear Toxin that could be absorbed through the skin, effectively making gas masks useless; though hazmat suits would be effective. Another project of theirs was the Cloudburst, a device that could spread the Fear Toxin as a giant cloud, while amplifying its potency; the Nimbus Cell powering it would effectively double as an EMP, disabling any electronics not powered by the cell. Secretly, Stagg sought to reverse-engineer the Fear Toxin to cure depression; he was annoyed with Crane's obsession with revenge against Batman, willing to take the formula by force if needed.
With two years worth of time to himself, Crane's mind began deteriorating at a much greater pace. With his hatred of Batman fueling him, Crane became a near-inversion of his former self, a cackling mad scientist dedicated to studying the effects of his research; he had now become more somber, though still dedicated to his study of fear. He had come to believe that fear was the very motivation for everything, even for Batman. Crane planned to cover the entire east coast of America in his Fear Toxin, turning it into "his domain"; in other words, Scarecrow wanted nothing more than to create complete and utter chaos. If Scarecrow wasn't stopped, eventually, the entire world would fall victim to his Fear Toxin and civilization would collapse.
At some point, Crane underwent facial reconstruction surgery. The end result was his face become more hideous than it already was, resembling his iconic mask with threads linking his jaw to what remained of his upper lips and two gas mask tubes attached to his jaw. Many who saw him found it hand to keep their lunches down; others wondered if he had taken a knife to his face and cut chunks of it out.
By this time, Scarecrow had established his main base on Arkham Island, after TYGER was disbanded following the attempt of Protocol 10. He was found by the Arkham Knight, who sought him out because he was the only foe Batman had faced that could attack him psychologically (aside for the Mad Hatter, who is hard to stand being around, let alone talk to); Scarecrow agreed to work with the Knight to break Batman and unmask him, though he explained that once Batman was broken, killing him would be an act of mercy.
To this end, Scarecrow called the remaining super criminals together; he met with Riddler privately, appealing to his ego, and coaxed him into launching his own challenge to Batman on Halloween as multiple threats would stretch the Dark Knight thin. Believing that Poison Ivy could further strengthen his Fear Toxin, Scarecrow tasked Harley with freeing her from Bludhaven's police department; Penguin was to guide Harley over the radio since she's stupid. Both feared Crane would gas them with Fear Toxin, so they barely managed cooperation.
With Ivy rescued, Scarecrow explained the plan to her, Harley, Two-Face and Penguin; they would force a mass evacuation of Gotham, leaving it to their gangs and the Knight's militia, thus outnumbering Batman and the GCPD. Ivy flatly refused, starting that she wasn't interest in his "petty human games"; thus Scarecrow knocked her out and sent Ivy to the gas chamber in his safe house in Chinatown. This way he could test the toxin on Ivy, while ensuring she couldn't use pheromones to brainwash the militia guarding her. To cover the cost of the Militia's equipment, Crane, Harley, Two-Face and Penguin paid a combined $3,000,000,000 to the Knight. They also hired the assassin Deathstroke as a back-up commander and adviser to the militia as he was the toughest foe Batman ever faced; they paid in advance, ensuring the mercenary's help.
The Knight also revealed a crucial piece of information to Scarecrow; Barbara Gordon was one of the Batman's allies. If they kidnapped her, this would break Batman's alliance with her father, leaving the Commissioner more vulnerable and reckless. Scarecrow favored the idea as it played on fear.
Later, Scarecrow and his allies contacted Mr. Freeze for assisting them with their nefarious plot; in exchange, they would provide better resources for helping him find a cure for his wife Nora. However, Victor declined their offer, having taken Batman's advice back in Arkham City to heart; he was staying away from crime and focusing all his attention on finding a cure for Nora. Annoyed, Scarecrow sent the militia to attack the ship Victor was using as his lab, taking Nora hostage with the promise of her return if Batman was brought to him.
Arkham Knight IncidentEdit
Nine months after Arkham City shut down, Scarecrow and his army initiated their plan. A member of the militia was sent to Pauli's Diner, with a bag of the fear toxin to make a public demonstration of its new potency; the patrons exposed to the gas tore at each other, with Officer Owens being the sole survivor. Scarecrow then publicly broadcast to all of Gotham, and explained that horrific scene was caused by just five ounces of Fear Toxin. He followed up with the threat to detonate bombs that contained the Fear Toxin around Gotham, which prompted a mass evacuation. Many of the criminals believed that Scarecrow must have a sense of humor as he chose Halloween for his attack.
However, only Batman and the outmatched GCPD were left to face Gotham's Most Wanted - who were under Scarecrow's "protection" - as well as the Knight's soldiers and drones. The militia used Founders' Island as their main base. Scarecrow spent most of his time here, broadcasting to the monitors in Gotham; this reminded some of the crooks of when Hugo Strange did the same thing back in Arkham City. Most of the criminals got tired of his lectures, wishing he would at least crack a joke or something. Ominously, Crane announced that soon all of Gotham would be receiving a gift from him; he would release his toxin upon the city, allowing those infected with it to become the dark beasts that they truly were inside.
Batman attacked his Chinatown safe-house, hoping to find him. Instead, all he found was militia troops guarding Poison Ivy, who was locked inside the gas chamber, strapped to a chair, with a guard discouraging escape attempts. After Batman took out the guards, the one next to Ivy radios Scarecrow, who appears on the screen in the back of the gas chamber. Crane explains that he is sorry to disappoint Batman with not being able to be there in person, but he will instead give a demonstration of what was to come later than night; he gassed the room, infecting the guard, who was promptly knocked out by Ivy. The toxin had no effect on her, since she had analyzed the toxin and made an antidote for it from plant spores. Ivy proceeded to explain Scarecrow's plan, while he sent militia drones to attack her and Batman; the attempt failed.
With the militias help, Scarecrow seized control of the Ace Chemicals Factory, where he set out to the Central Mixing Chamber, to mass produce the Fear Toxin to create a bomb powerful enough to take out the entire Eastern Seaboard. The Arkham Knight was to give final warning of when the explosion would go off, but Crane didn't care if there were still any troops around; infecting others with his Fear Toxin was all that mattered to him. When Batman and the GCPD arrived on site, the Knight destroyed the bridge to the facility with his attack chopper. Though the Arkham Knight wanted to kill Batman on sight (and thus make all of their planning moot), Scarecrow overrode his vehicle's systems, stated that if he killed Batman, he'd have nothing left to fear, and ordered him keep Batman away from Ace Chemicals until his work was complete.
After Batman evacuated the two surviving Ace Chemicals workers from the site, he confronted Scarecrow in the Central Mixing Chamber. Maintaining his composure, Crane knelt down with both of his hands behind his head, and showed no resistance. However, Batman smashed his head against the control panel, and demanded to know how the Fear Toxin could be stopped. Confident, Crane explained that it's impossible to stop, and that the building would soon explode and release his Fear Toxin. Scarecrow then warned the Dark Knight to release him, claiming that Barbara Gordon would be killed if he didn't comply. Batman distracted himself to contact the Clock Tower, at which point Oracle was abducted. Scarecrow escaped, and locked Batman in; departing, he taunted Batman by telling him that nothing hurts more than the death of someone closest to you.Scarecrow left Batman to perish in the explosion that would consume ACE Chemicals, departing in a Militia helicopter to watch his Fear Toxin cover Gotham. However, Batman managed to put enough neutralizing agents in the mix to reduce the blast radius to just the area around the factory before the building collapsed. Having seen that his main plan had failed, Scarecrow realized that Batman must have escaped his trap, and would resume hunting for him. Crane realized that he would have to resort to the more time-consuming Plan B.
After the ACE Chemicals incident, Crane returned to the militia's HQ, where he would keep tabs on Batman's progress with fighting Gotham's Most Wanted. Scarecrow continued taunting Batman via the monitors, insisting that everything that happened to Batman's allies was the Dark Knight's own fault, and that his efforts over the years were pointless. At one point, he wondered if Batman had thought he was dead before this Halloween night, due to his near-death experience back at the Asylum. Noting that Batman used fear to control thugs, Scarecrow declared that he has usurped the "the throne" the Dark Knight ruled from; Scarecrow saw himself as "the sovereign" now.
Under the threat of death from the Arkham Knight, Scarecrow was forbidden from harming Barbara Gordon or injecting his Fear Toxin into her; unknown to him, the Knight was actually an old friend of Barbara's that still had a soft spot for her despite his hatred of Batman.
Scarecrow had the militia harpoon Stagg's airships and pull them back to Founders' Island, needing the Cloudburst for his Plan B. He had the Knight lock the unsuspecting Stagg in an experimentation cell as punishment for double-crossing him. Crane then went to prep the Cloudburst, ordering the militia to begin supplying power to it as knew Batman would catch wind of this. At the time, Batman had found the holding cells containing the victims of Crane's experiments, and was interrogating Stagg about his whereabouts. When Stagg began talking about the Cloudburst, Crane gassed him remotely to keep Stagg silent.
Scarecrow soon found no Nimbus cells were being sent to charge the Cloudburst, meaning Batman had taken out his guards; he awaited the Dark Knight's entrance. Batman found him, but Crane was able to gas him with Fear Toxin; unbeknownst to Scarecrow, he was only able to do this because Batman was seeing hallucinations of the Joker, and had picked one disguised as him by accident.
Batman writhed in agony on the ground, trying to fight off the effects of Crane's fear toxin. Crane paced around, taunting Batman, explaining that he would soon remove the Dark Knight's mask and show the world that he was nothing more than a man forced to face his fears. Once this happened, the people of Gotham would no longer have a savior to give them hope as there would be no more Batman. Taking Scarecrow by surprise, Batman said he has already disappeared; tossed aside, an astonished Crane decided to watch this new reaction in Batman play out.
What Scarecrow didn't know was that the consciousness of the Joker had surfaced in the Dark Knight and was ready to take his body for a test drive. The possessed Batman proceeded to pummel the militia soldiers that came to backup Scarecrow within an inch of their lives, as the mad doctor watched in amazement; Crane wrongly concluded that Batman was simply now reacting properly to his fear toxin. As the effects of the toxin faded, Batman regained control of his body, and Crane remarked something about him seemed different. When warned by Batman that there was nowhere to run, Crane back up to the wall and laughed "Who said anything about running?" At that moment, Scarecrow braced himself by holding on the ladder at the wall it was attached to, and the Cloudburst was torn away from the airship by a helicopter piloted by the Arkham Knight.
Crane informed Batman that Oracle was being held captive at his Chinatown safe-house; when Batman arrived, Scarecrow doused Barbara with Fear Toxin. Seeing Batman as something horrible due to its effects, Barbara used a gun in the room to try shooting him; however, the glass was re-enforced. Hopeless, Barbara listened to Crane's persuasion to "deny him"; she shot herself in the head. However, this was a hallucination that Batman had, brought on by Fear Toxin pumped into the room by Crane; this even fooled Detective Mode. Barbara was actually still very much alive, but unaffected by the toxin due to being sealed in the gas chamber. Scarecrow later had Barbara retrieved from the safe-house once the Fear Toxin dispersed.
Crane kept the fact that Barbara was still alive a secret, hoping to push the Dark Knight further and further, until his facade broke and everyone saw the fraud he truly was. He contacted Batman through the monitors again, asking what it was like to see the hallucination react to seeing "his true self" - whatever kind of monster the fear gas would make Batman look like; he defended this action, calling it necessary, not cruelty. As Batman never responded to him, Scarecrow began wondering aloud if the Dark Knight's mask helped push down any actual emotion that he should be feeling.
Unknown to Scarecrow, Batman had his Batwing circling the three islands to find the Cloudburst, which gave off a unique energy signature; at the time, more Nimbus Cells were being loaded into the device, leaving it vulnerable to being destroyed. Due to the fact that two enormous plants had erupted out of the ground on Miagani island, Scarecrow released that an unlikely alliance had be struck between Batman and Poison Ivy; the two were working together to revive plants with pollen able to neutralize the effects of this new strain of Fear Toxin. Crane broadcast to Gotham again, telling Batman that it was nothing more than a wasted effort; however, he did wonder how the Dark Knight was able to persuade Ivy to help save a city that she deeply despised, when he had failed in getting her to side with him and the rest of the villains.
Likely unknown to Scarecrow, there was a side-effect to his latest batch of Fear Toxin; it would cause the destruction of any plant life infected with it. Not willing to allow Scarecrow to wither away all the vegetation in Gotham, Poison Ivy had chosen the lesser of two evils and sided with Batman to stop him. Scarecrow sent the militia's drones to attack the plants, hoping to find the one Ivy was hiding in; with her dead, nothing would be able to hinder his efforts to unleash terror upon Gotham. However, this proved to be ineffective thanks Ivy manipulating the roots to crush the tanks, with Batman assisting in the Batmobile.
Seeing no other way to accomplish his plans, Scarecrow finished powering the Cloudburst and had it attached to the Arkham Knight's personal tank, sending him to Bleake Island to activate Plan B. Seen from all around Gotham, a large blast of fear toxin was launched from the machine, high into the sky; it exploded, releasing an electrified fear cloud that swallowed Miagani, Bleake and Founders' islands. The rest of Gotham was left untouched by the release of the fear cloud, allowing those still unaffected to see the horror.
Within the confines of the infected area, all the rioters had begun attacking each other in terror; each was seeing whatever it was that they feared most in place of their fellow criminals. Gotham was left glowing orange from the fear cloud, which was sustained by the Cloudburst. As a side-effect of using the Cloudburst, the Batmobile was left inoperable as it did not run on a Nimbus Cell.
Once the bust had subsided, Scarecrow broadcasted to Gotham again, stating that it had been transformed into his City of Fear. Having been exposed to his toxins, the inhabitants of Gotham have now seen Batman wasn't unstoppable and had finally failed them. The Cloudburst also had the effects of amplifying the toxin to the point were it was leeching the life from the plant-life in Gotham. To keep the plants from dying, Ivy connected herself to them, feeding them her own life energy to keep them alive. Aware of this, Scarecrow broadcasted again, telling Batman that while his toxin attacks the human mind, it's killing Poison Ivy.
Batman proceeded back to Stagg's airship, where he knocked out the militia guarding the hole left by the theft of the Cloudburst. Stagg had escaped from his cell, forcing Scarecrow to order the other half to the group to find and silence him, to keep any remaining information about the Cloudburst secret. Batman knocked them out and confined Stagg in one of his own specimen cages; he proceeded to take a Nimbus Cell, to re-power the Batmobile. Batman braved the fear toxin cloud, refitting the Batmobile with the Cell, and headed off to destroy the Cloudburst. With the bridges on Bleake Island being cut off remotely, Scarecrow ordered the Knight to retreat; however, the Knight ignored him, deciding that now was the time to kill Batman.
Batman took out the Cobra drones escorting the Knight's tank, one-by-one; each time, Scarecrow ordered the Arkham Knight to make a strategic retreat. However, much to his anger, Scarecrow was ignored; he even pointed out that the Clouburst was HIS property, not bait to lure out Batman. Unfortunately, the Dark Knight scanned the tank, learning of the cooling systems that kept the Cloudburst from exploding. He attacked them and the main body of the tank, leaving the Knight without any means of escape.
Scarecrow continued watching these events, seeing Batman drag the Knight out of his tank and onto a rooftop. The Knight attempted to choke Batman, who pinned him and proceeded to pummel him. However, Batman began hallucinating again, allowing the Knight to flee. Scarecrow told the waiting Deathstroke that he now had his chance to go after Batman, letting him use the majority of the militia however he pleased. Without the Cloudburst to maintain it, the Fear Toxin cloud was cleared away by Poison Ivy; however, the strain of doing so cost Ivy her life. Comforted by Batman, she dissolved into dust and blew away in the wind.
The rogues were left enraged that Scarecrow had subjected them to such horrors. Crane was then left to rethink his plans, deciding to again focus on unmasking and breaking Batman. He broadcast to Gotham, explaining the militia now obeys him, and that while his fear toxin was cleared away, he had succeeded in breaking the faith Gotham had placed in Batman; the Dark Knight was not as omnipotent as everyone had thought he was. Adding onto this was the long time the city would need to recover from the attack.
Crane soon captures Gordon, who had tracked him down to rescue Barbara. The deranged Master of Fear offered the overprotective father a deal; he would release Barbara, in exchange for bringing Batman to him. Though disappointed with the Arkham Knight, Crane allows him to use Gordon as bait to lure Batman to his secret HQ. This leads to the successful destruction of the Batmobile, by the Knight's giant excavator. The fight between the two leads into the HQ, where the Knight reveals himself to be Jason Todd, Robin 2; having been tortured by the Joker for over a year in an abandoned wing of Arkham, and then abandoned, Jason had focused all his pain into a monomaniac hatred of Batman, who he blamed for his ordeal. After Batman shows kindness to him, the Knight vanishes into the city, leaving Scarecrow in charge of the remaining forces.
Per the agreement struck between them, Gordon lead Batman to an elevator leading them to the roof on a building under construction. Meeting together, Crane reveals Oracle is alive and the pact he made with Gordon, ordering him to carry out his end of the deal by threatening to push Barbara off the building. Gordon intentionally shot Batman in the chest (where he knew that Batman's armor was the strongest) and Batman fell off the building. But Scarecrow, who didn't want Batman dead, pushed Oracle off the building where Batman caught her mid-air. Though Barbara was safe, Crane made his leave with the Militia forces and Gordon as his hostage by helicopter. He sent drones to check and see if Batman lived; not only was the Dark Knight still alive, he had a second Batmobile, which reduced the drones to scrap metal.
After Batman returned Barbara to the GCPD Lockup, Scarecrow send drones to assault the GCPD building; using this as a distraction, Crane used Gordon to access Panessa Studios. He likely learned about the victims of Joker's blood and wanted to see if he could use them in his research. Instead, he found their corpses and both Robin and Harley Quinn locked up in cells. Though Robin attempted to attack them, once released from his cell, the militia succeed in subduing him and breaking his bo staff. Scarecrow then had his mark painted on the cell, as a calling card to Batman, hoping that with two hostages, he had twice the control over Batman's fears. However, he also refused to release Harley, who held no further purpose in his plans.
Batman later returns and sees the scene, being informed by Harley about what happened and of where the next message from Scarecrow would come from. Appearing on a monitor at storage depot in Kingston, Crane informed Batman that if he wanted to save Robin and Gordon, he had to surrender himself to him. Batman accepted, turned himself over to Scarecrow, and abandoned his utility belt. Batman then entered a van and was driven to Arkham Island, where Scarecrow was waiting for him. After he arrived at the Arkham Mansion at the abandoned Arkham Asylum, Batman found Gordon and Robin being held captive by Scarecrow.
Scarecrow revealed he was broadcasting live across the city, seeking to make Gordon unmask Batman so that Gotham could see their beloved hero's face as he succumbed to the Fear Toxin. Initially, Gordon protested, so Scarecrow shot Robin in the chest. Robin lived due to his suit's armor, but Scarecrow threatened to shoot him in the head if Gordon didn't cooperate. Batman told Gordon it was the only way and the Commissioner reluctantly unmasked him; upon Batman's unmasking, the televisions showing the broadcast and its reaction were full of shock as the Dark Knight was revealed to be Bruce Wayne.
Surprised to see that his old foe was a supposed billionaire playboy, Scarecrow continued on with his plan; he explained that he wouldn't be killing Batman, but would instead "set him free". This "freedom" he spoke of was to watch as Gotham tore itself apart in a frenzy at the shock of learning Batman's true identity, and to watch all many of Gotham's criminals attacked his allies in hopes of getting revenge for all that Batman has done to them. Scarecrow then proceeded to inject Bruce with his fear toxin, hoping to expose him as a fraud. He then watched as Batman began writhing in agony as the toxin began taking hold on his mind.
Inside Batman's head, he raced through the burning Gotham City using the Batmobile in his mind in order to defeat giant Scarecrow to break some of the influence over him (as shown in the Scarecrow Nightmare Missions), and then went on to eradicate the influence of the Joker in his mind. Turning around, Scarecrow saw Batman fighting off the Fear Toxin, and proclaimed that he wasn't afraid. An angered Crane continuously injected Batman with Fear Toxin, but the hero constantly fought off the effects.
Due to his apparent inability to feel fear, Crane deemed Batman's life "meaningless" and pointed his gun to Batman's head. Just as Scarecrow attempted to pull the trigger, the gun was suddenly shot out of his hand. The shooter was revealed to be Jason Todd, who had rechristened himself as the ruthless vigilante Red Hood. Jason then reloaded his rifle and shot the strap of the gurney that Batman was restrained in as Crane attempted to stab him in the head with his razor glove as a last desperate resort. Batman grabbed Scarecrow's hand and exposed him to his own Fear Toxin. Hallucinating his fear of bats, Crane began to see swarms of bats flying around him, and Batman as a demonic bat like creature, he then began screaming in horror and attempted to flee, but was subdued by Gordon. Crane was then brought to the GCPD Lockup and handed over to the custody of Aaron Cash, who put him in with the other villains that Batman caught.
As the Knightfall Protocol began, Scarecrow was likely still under the influence of his own Fear Toxin and was most likely put on trial alongside all of his allies. His charges likely included kidnapping, assault with a deadly weapon, conspiracy, attempted murder, acts of terrorism, torture, and aiding and abetting known felons.
Given that Crane's mind appears to be completely gone, it's not likely he can be charged; only those who can comprehend what they've done are given charges. Humiliated, beaten, and mentally broken, Scarecrow was taken to the GCPD Lockup, where he would remain locked up for the rest of his life along with his fellow criminals.
Scarecrow underwent an extreme personality change between Arkham Asylum and Arkham Knight, that was presumably due to being driven into a bitter traumatization after his near-death experience with Killer Croc.
In Arkham Asylum, Scarecrow closely followed his over-the-top comic book portrayal: a downright, sadistic villain who took glee in murdering innocent people and/or driving them into insanity, complete with a high-pitched voice with a loud and dramatic tone to it. As evidenced by his audio tapes, Scarecrow was extremely intelligent and manipulative, as he managed to convince one of the asylum doctors that he wasn't insane. Scarecrow did the same to Dr. Young, who even believed that he was innocent. Scarecrow treated the concept of fear like a religion, said that almost every action you did was solely because of fear, and proved his megalomania by wanting to control fear and use it to gain power. This is further shown in Arkham Knight where after detonating the Cloudburst, drowning Gotham in his toxin he proudly describes it the "city of fear" and "my domain."
In Arkham Knight, two years after Arkham Asylum, Scarecrow was almost a complete inversion of his former self. He possessed an incredibly calm and deep voice, and spoke in a soft-spoken monotone. While he was a giggling psychopath in Asylum, Scarecrow was an emotionless mastermind who only laughed twice. He still retained his sadism, his unmatchable brilliance, his religious dedication to fear, and proved himself to be a omnicidal maniac, as he planned to cover the entire Earth in Fear Toxin starting with the Eastern Seaboard.
His bio also mentioned that after years of forcefully being injected with it thanks to Batman, Scarecrow was utterly immune to not only his own Fear Toxin, but fear itself, as not a single concept could arouse him into a fearful state, except bats. That fear may be natural, but could also be caused thanks to Batman. Even when being face-to-face to a wildly angered Batman, Detective Mode proved that Scarecrow was still calm. Scarecrow's only examples of emotion was temporary fury when the Cloudburst was destroyed, and when he was permanently reduced into a terrified, mumbling mess after a colossal dosage of his own Fear Toxin that was injected into him by Batman at the Arkham Mansion.
Scarecrow's psyche was fractured so much after Arkham Asylum, that he didn't care about Batman's true identity as long as he got to destroy him and show the world who was really behind the cowl. Scarecrow's obsession with fear became even more warped, which lead him to desire to coat the world in his Fear Toxin to destroy millions of minds.
Whereas in Arkham Asylum he treated fear as a religion which governs every actions of every day, given Arkham Knight he has begun to see it as a fundamental factor of life and without it, life itself would be meaningless. This can be attributed to his obsession with laying bare the legend of Batman, proving to the world that he was just a man and nothing more, as witnessing a man who was by all means fearless was an insult, almost blasphemy to Scarecrow's views of life, a prospect of his fear-religious ideals. As a person, who was essentially a man of fear he understood that hope was the catalyst of terror, and has shown multiple times to be against its concepts. As Batman was the embodiment of hope in Gotham by unmasking him Scarecrow would equivalently be taking all which he stood for, placing Gotham in a (literal) reign of fear without his protection.
Batman: Arkham Asylum EditLike most villains in the series, Scarecrow's appearance changed depending on setting, materials and even his psychological condition. The basis for Scarecrow's costume may have been similar to his mainstream DC Comics counterpart, referencing the Headless Horseman trick from Sleepy Hollow and the Scarecrow from The Wizard of Oz, inspired by his love of reading, and a rather on the nose symbol for the role that he wished to play in his victim's terror. Before the events of Arkham Asylum, Scarecrow used a costume that was slightly similar to his comic appearance, which incorporated an actual scarecrow-like appearance with a burlap mask that showed his eyes and mouth, and was topped off with a hat and a cloak. After he was captured and released, Crane may have had to scavenge for materials to complete the costume that was seen in the game. Scarecrow was shirtless, and his trousers, cowl, and sleeves appeared to be woven together from various rags, possibly from an Arkham inmate uniform. His mask had been altered into a cowl with the aesthetics of a hood and a noose, and acted as a gas mask. Scarecrow wore a brace over his right hand with syringes that extended over his fingers, which allowed him to simultaneously attack and inject a victim with Fear Toxin if they didn't breath in his gas. Scarecrow was often seen hunched over so that his skin was hardly visible and looked more like a scarecrow.
Batman: Arkham Knight Edit
Scarecrow's appearance was vastly different due to the injuries that he had sustained at the hands of Killer Croc back at Arkham Asylum. Scarecrow may have been blind in one eye and his face seemed to be damaged: it was no longer clear how much of his face was a mask or scar tissue. His left leg may have been permanently broken, as it was secured in a leg brace. Strangely, even with his broken leg, Scarecrow stood much taller than in Arkham Asylum, though in the former incident, Crane walked hunched over.
Crane's new gas mask also appeared to be surgically grafted to his throat, as it didn't cover his mouth or nose. It was mentioned by random Militia chatter that after Killer Croc's attack on him at Arkham Asylum, Crane underwent surgery to make his face appear as it did in Arkham Knight, which meant that the mask wasn't a mask, it was his actual face: he surgically grafted the mask to his face. Crane may have sustained damage to his windpipe that necessitated a respiratory bypass, which explained why his voice was so much more gravelly than before. Another possibility was that Scarecrow's voice in Arkham Asylum could of not been his real voice and altered it to make it more scary. Another piece of evidence to support that theory was the presence of two tubes going into the underside of Crane's lower jaw, with one of them being attached to one of his Fear Toxin canisters. Whether or not Crane took micro doses of his own Fear Toxin to make himself immune to it was unknown.
To better wage his war, Scarecrow wore a trench coat that was modified to hold multiple vials of Fear Toxin, which provided him with a larger supply. Scarecrow's fingertip syringes were upgraded to include claws that were latched to his wrist for combat. Altogether, Scarecrow resembled an undead being.
Dr. Penelope YoungEdit
Real Name: Dr. Jonathan Crane
Possibly one of my greatest successes here at the asylum. Despite his tendency for extensive role-play (oddly common among Gotham City's criminals), it's unclear to me why Dr. Crane was ever considered insane. In our long discussions, I've been impressed with his genius for psychology and biochemistry, and I fully believe that if presented with a stock of his fear-inducing gas, he would feel no compulsion to use it. He seems to have entirely turned away from his former life of crime as the Scarecrow.
He's valiantly battled a history of anxiety disorder, due to a difficult childhood and adulthood trauma, through an intense study of psychology and the causes of fear.
I've come to believe that the accusations that he experimented on human subjects are wildly exaggerated.
GENIUS at Chemistry!
Would he have something to contribute to 'Titan' research?
- Master of Fear.
- Obsessed with creating fear in others.
- Professor of psychology.
- Expert psychiatrist and biochemist.
- Employs a fear-inducing psychoactive that creates nightmarish hallucinations.
- Jonathan Crane: Patient Interview 1. Patient was referred to me after the incident with Dr. Murphy. He appears to have suffered a breakdown of sorts. I believe it was brought about after the loss of his wife and child. As yet, the patient has been unable to speak. Continued observation shows little mental activity. It's as if the shock of what he saw triggered his mental collapse.
- Security Guard: There's someone in here! It's him! We've found him! Break down the door!
- Jonathan Crane: Note to self. As ever, it is difficult to continue my research under such conditions.
- Security Guard: Step away from Dr. Combs. Now! Get down on the ground! We've found them. Someone get a medic! Oh God, what's he done to him?
- Dr. Stephen Kellerman: Patient interview 6. Dr. Crane has been back in custody for 3 weeks. Regular sessions have been inconclusive. I am not sure he is actually insane.
- Jonathan Crane: Good evening, Stephen. How are you tonight?
- Dr. Stephen Kellerman: I'm conducting the session, Jonathan.
- Jonathan Crane: Of course. If that helps you cope, I wouldn't have it any other way.
- Dr. Stephen Kellerman: Let's talk about the events 3 weeks ago. What did you think you'd achieve? Dr. Murphy is still in therapy.
- Jonathan Crane: I wanted to understand him. His personal demons. His fears. It's all quite fascinating, really.
- Dr. Stephen Kellerman: But you are... were a respected doctor. A brilliant mind, now just another resident in Arkham.
- Jonathan Crane: Can I have a drink? A strong one? This kind of question bores me.
- Dr. Stephen Kellerman: I'm afraid not.
- Jonathan Crane: Interesting choice of words, Doctor. Tell me, what are you afraid of?
- Dr. Stephen Kellerman: Patient interview 9. Dr. Crane continues to evade questions. I believe he is quite sane. Just evil. He takes no interest in the people he has hurt. His research appears to be the only motivating factor in his life. What is it about fear that drives your obsessions?
- Jonathan Crane: Fear drives everything, Stephen. Everything. Your life is governed by fear. Every decision you make is a product of that fear.
- Dr. Stephen Kellerman: Don't be ridiculous.
- Jonathan Crane: You married your wife...Margaret, isn't it?...because you were scared of dying alone. You have children because you are scared of leaving nothing behind that really matters. You go to the doctors because you're scared of dying. Do I need to go on?
- Dr. Stephen Kellerman: No. I think that will be all for today. Guards!
- Dr. Stephen Kellerman: Today I have another interview with Crane. I cannot say I am looking forward to it. I've been feeling anxious. I don't like to admit it, but...I think he's getting to me.
- Jonathan Crane: How are you today?
- Dr. Stephen Kellerman: I keep telling you, this is my session.
- Jonathan Crane: It was your session, Doctor, but not anymore.
- Security Guard: Are you OK, doc?
- Dr. Stephen Kellerman: I think...yes..I...
- Jonathan Crane: Oh, he's fine. Just questioning his grip on reality. You should be doing the same any second...
- Security Guard: Mom, is that you? Wait, what are you doing?
- Dr. Stephen Kellerman: Get off of me... Help. I need help here. I can't breathe...
- Jonathan Crane: Like I said... You're all part of my experiment now!
- Jonathan Crane: Asylum interview 1. My experiment is underway. Working alone, I have created my ultimate Fear Gas, its potency a revelation.
- Dr. Stephen Kellerman: Ah! Ahh! They're all over me!
- Security Guard: Please, daddy, don't do it! Ah! Ahh!
- Dr. Stephen Kellerman: Keep away! Keep away! Keep away!
- Jonathan Crane: I have pumped enough gas into the Medical Center to break 100 minds. It should only be a matter of time before... [Sound of glass shattering] What?
- Batman: Give it up, now!
- Jonathan Crane: How...how are you still standing? How come it's not affecting you?
- Batman: Who says it's not?
- Jonathan Crane: I knew it. What was it like? What have you seen?
- Batman: Officer Cash. Get this formula to the air-conditioning system. Now! You failed, Crane. Again. I've been working with Dr. Kellerman, creating an antidote to the toxins in your cologne. He fooled you, Crane. How does that make you feel? Threatened, humiliated? Scared?
Batman: Arkham Asylum Edit
- "There is no Crane...Only Scarecrow!"
- "Poor little Bat. You're in my world now."
- "Is the world falling apart or just your mind? Are you scared? Embrace it."
- "Look around you. These are the broken fragments of your mind!"
- "Are you scared, little Bat? Do you need your mommy?"
- "I will tear your mind apart!"
- "Your mind will shatter like glass!"
- "What are you, Batman? Chicken?"
- "There's no escape!"
- "Everything you see is under my control!"
- "I will break you!"
- "What was that?"
- "What are you doing, little Bat?"
- "There you are, Batman!"
- "Stay still, this won't hurt!"
- "Dare to step into my gaze!"
- "I see you, Batman!"
- "I know you're there."
- "What are you trying to do?"
- "Do you believe what you see, Batman?"
- "Are you scared to come out and face your fears, Batman?"
- "Just got to check your prisoner, dear!" (Harley Quinn, illusion)
- "No, he's not. We really should feel sorry for him. He never fully got over his parent's death. It left him quite insane." (Batman, illusion)
- "What is going on inside your head, Wayne? Bah, he's gone! Just a twisted shell of a man." (Batman, illusion)
- "He's all yours, Joker!" (Batman, illusion)
- "I think you need a little more!"
- "Tell me, what demons do you have left to beat? Shall we see?"
- "Are you enjoying the extra dose, little Bat?"
- "Oh, I won't rush things this time. I'm going to savor every moment of your terror as I slowly destroy you."
- "You're fighting back. Good. It can only weaken your resolve."
- "How much more do you think you can take? Does it scare you to know that I have almost defeated you?"
- "How are you doing this?"
- "You've ingested enough toxins to drive ten men insane. What are you?"
- "Why fight it, Batman? You're as crazy as the rest of us. You need us as much as we need you. And to prove it, I'll flood the catacombs with enough Fear Gas to break the minds of everyone in Gotham for a hundred years."
- "Too late, Batman!"
- "One step closer... and this goes into the water!"
- "The cave will fill with your deepest, darkest nightmares and you will never reach your precious Venom roots."
Batman: Arkham KnightEdit
- "Gotham, this is your only warning, abandon the city, or I will unleash your greatest fears." (Trailer)
- "How many more bones will you crush? How many lives will you destroy in the pursuit of what you call justice? You are the product of everything you fear: violence, darkness, helplessness. All that remains is for you to watch, as I drag your beloved Gotham into oblivion." (Trailer)
- "This demonstration used just five ounces of my latest toxin.
- "Tomorrow, this will seem like child's play."
- "Gotham, this is your only warning."
- "Were you expecting to find me, Batman? I'm afraid I must disappoint you."
- "Take a look at the chamber. I want you to know the fear that is coming." (To Batman about Poison Ivy)
- "Remnants of Gotham, I have messages for you all. To the vandals who stayed behind to pick the still warm flesh from Gotham's bones: Have your fun. You are under my protection. To the cowards quaking behind the police department's walls: You will not be spared. And to Batman: I have already won. Emptied your city with a vial of toxin and a few threatening words. That's how little the safety you provided was worth. And when the dawn comes...when Gotham lies in ruins and I turn my gaze to the world beyond...the legend of the Batman will be worth nothing at all."
- "In death he has nothing left to fear. Keep him away from ACE Chemicals. Your vengeance will come." (To the Arkham Knight about Batman)
- "We have not broken him yet. It will come." (To the Arkham Knight about Batman)
- "Why do you hate him so much?" (To the Arkham Knight about Batman)
- "Your revenge is at hand. This is his last night." (To the Arkham Knight about Batman)
- "Is the strike team ready?" (The Arkham Knight)
- "The asset is a crucial element of my plan. Do not disappoint me." (The Arkham Knight)
- "Gentlemen, tonight is the night that Gotham changes forever. The night it becomes a wasteland of nightmares, a forsaken symbol of Batman's failure, a monument to fear." (Militia Soldiers)
- "But more than that: we're about to turn Gotham into the epicenter of a blast that will transform the entire Eastern coast of America into MY domain." (Militia Soldiers)
- "Need I remind you that we are on a tight schedule here? Gotham is going to pay for what its 'savior' did to me." (Militia Soldiers)
- "You each have been given a task. Complete that task and pray that you will not experience my fear toxin firsthand." (Militia Soldiers)
- "The people of Gotham can run all they like, but they will not avoid their fate." (Militia Soldiers)
- "Each element you carry is vital to my plan. My toxin's design has been perfected over of clinical trials. The speed at which it enters the bloodstream is matched only by the ferocity with which it takes hold." (Militia Soldiers)
- "Once released into the atmosphere, the gas cloud will cover the entire Eastern seaboard. From there it has the potential to reach the farthest corners of the continent. An entire nation gripped by fear. By my estimates, the fallout will last for a century or more." (Militia Soldiers)
- "It appears that the flow of chemicals has stopped, which can only mean that you are here, Batman. I've been looking forward to seeing you again."
- "I thought you brave enough to confront me."
- "I know you're out there. The door is open."
- "Do you really think you've won?"
- "Fear makes you predictable."
- "I am in complete control."
- "Let me go, or she dies."
- "Barbara Gordon."
- "Nothing hurts like losing one of the family, knowing that there is no one to blame but yourself."
- "You might fool everyone else, but you can't fool me. There's something different about you. You're afraid."
- "You've always buried your fears, locked them away deep in your subconscious. Hidden. But something is gnawing away in the darkness of your mind, isn't it? Something even you can't control."
- "The cracks are forming as it pushes its way to the surface. I can almost taste it."
- "Chase after your ally, Bat, if you can through a city MY army now controls. With luck, you'll find her before I show you how tonight is really going to end."
- "You raised yourself above them, Batman, inspired the herd. But what happens when their idol falls from his pedestal in front of their eyes."
- "It all falls apart, Batman. Everything you worked for. The peace you built on a foundation of sand."
- "It's gone, Dark Knight-the grip you had on Gotham. Your long reign of fear. I'm sovereign now."
- "He despises you, this Arkham Knight. What did you do, hero, to enkindle such hatred?"
- "Did you think you stopped me at ACE Chemicals, Batman? You merely delayed the inevitable."
- "Gotham is mine, to do with as I please. And the same can be said of your friend."
- 'Poor little Barbara Gordon. Close your eyes. Can you see her? Cowering in the darkness? Cursing the hero who failed her?"
- "She has become your weakness, your obsession, dragging you deeper into the abyss."
- "I could have her killed right now. It would be cruel. Sadistic. Brutal. But I have other plans in store for both of you."
- "Gentlemen, an announcement. Our one-time friend Mr. Stagg neglected to keep the Cloudburst charged and ready for operation. We will need to do the job ourselves."
- "I need men in Biological Engineering ferrying energy cells to charge the device, and I need more men to defend them. Do not fail me."
- "Our work is nearly done. My calibrations are almost complete and the Cloudburst will soon be charged. Until then, keep supplying me with energy cells."
- "Are you afraid of what I will do when the Cloudburst is charged? Don't be. I have guaranteed your protection. Fear what will happen to you should you fail to charge it."
- "Not yet. The Cloudburst must be fully charged."
- "You're not dying, it just feels like you are. My toxin is filling your lungs, drowning you in your greatest fears."
- "What can you see? A city engulfed in fear? Betrayed by those you trust the most? Your darkest secrets revealed?"
- "As I tear your mind apart, Gotham will watch. I will cut that mask from your face, and the whole world will see the fear in your eyes. Then they too will understand. There is no savior. No more hope... No more Batman."
- "Astonishing. Such brutality."
- "You almost killed these men. You were ready to abandon your beliefs, everything you stand for."
- "You tell yourself you are not like us. You tell yourself you are something more, something better."
- "But fear reveals the truth, erodes your self-control. Soon you will kill and become that which you hate the most. Soon, the Bat will be broken!"
- "Something's changed. You're different!"
- "Who said anything about running?"
- "How does it feel to see your city on the brink of ruin, your friends in the clutches of death?"
- "You stretched yourself too far this time, Batman, and now your failure is all but complete."
- "As that final dying breath escapes her body, she will know you are the one who failed her."
- "We both know fear is theatrics, Batman, so permit me the indulgence of putting on this show."
- "Yes, you see it now. The horror behind the glass, the monster that will be your end... unless you pick up that gun and deny him."
- "You will bring death to all who follow you."
- "Batman, what happened at the safehouse was not some cruel game. It was necessary."
- "Tonight is about more than Gotham. It's about what you became in that room. The hero who failed. That's what I want the world to see."
- "Do you mourn, Batman? Or are you really the stoic caricature you play? Beneath that mask is a man, I'm sure. A man who grieves, a man who suffers. A man who fears the reckoning to come."
- "Do you still see it, Batman? The terror in her eyes as she looked upon your true self? Savor that image. There are many like it still to come."
- "Good. Are we still on schedule?"
- "Your patience will be rewarded soon."
- "Welcome to Gotham...The City of Fear."
- "Do you see this, Batman? Your poisoned, desolate city? Its people tearing out each other's throats, their own throats, in terror? The world sees it too. Next, the world will see what happens to the man who tries to stop me. And when it does, the world will know fear. You aren't fighting for Gotham, tonight. You're fighting for every desperate fool who thinks that when their worst fears come to pass, a hero might come and save them. And you're losing."
- "Do you see them? All the monsters you created."
- "My toxin will fill the streets, and bring this city to it's knees. I will take from you everything you fear to lose, and I will watch you suffer. Scared yet?"
- "What do you seek on those tunnels, Batman? Hope? You will find none."
- "How did you persuade Poison Ivy to come rallying to the aid of a city she despises? Threats? Blackmail? Charm?"
- "She's dying. My toxin strikes at the minds of humans, but it leeches the life from her."
- "Dr. Isley cannot stop me. But how noble you were to make her Gotham's first line of defense."
- "How can the world know fear-true dread-when it has you? A stalwart knight, ever ready to slay monsters. Fear isn't pure biology, Batman. It's more than instinct. True fear is the absence of hope. And hope is the spread wings of a Bat, shining on the clouds."
- "You promised that Gotham would be safe. Protected! But what does the world see now?! My toxin choking its streets! Blotting out the moonlight! Poisoning the saplings you thought could stop me!"
- "And now, Dark Knight, I turn to you. But don't be afraid. It's not your life that needs ending, it's your myth. The hope that you stand for. The hope that dies tonight."
- "Don't fret. This tree won't make any difference. Ivy isn't strong enough to purify Gotham. No one is."
- "Your escort is almost gone, Knight. Protect the Cloudburst, withdraw."
- "What do you think you're doing?"
- "This is not the plan we agreed upon."
- "He's trying to overheat the cloudburst. Leave now."
- "You will have your chance to kill him."
- "The cloudburst is not bait, Knight. It is mine."
- "The cloudburst won't withstand another strike. Retreat."
- "Batman! The Cloudburst was mine! My greatest weapon! My instrument of fear! I will exact vengeance for this on you and all your allies. Like Poison Ivy. My toxin overwhelms her. She's paying the price for opposing me right now."
- "You actually believe you've won, don't you, Batman? Savor this fleeting delusion of victory."
- "The Arkham Knight may have fled in terror, but now his army answers to ME!"
- "For even as my toxin dissipates, it leaves behind a forsaken city, forever tainted by your failure."
- "Tonight, the myth of Batman dies and Gotham dies with it."
- "Batman has arrived ahead of schedule. Lock down the elevators and find him."
- "Do you still believe that you are Gotham's savior? Soon, the world will see you for what you truly are: a fallacy, a figment of hope in a world of suffering and pain."
- "How many more bones will you crush? How many lives will you destroy in the pursuit of your crude justice? We are all products of our fears: I look at you and see a man born of violence and darkness."
- "What will you give to save your friends, I wonder? Are you ready to reveal your secret? Are ready for your legend to die?"
- "The commissioner placed his trust in you, to keep his city safe, his family safe. Can you still atone for your failure? Are you still the master of your own destiny? The answers are waiting, Batman, as am I."
- "Stop this, Knight. Everything is in hand."
- "We had a plan. He is going to suffer."
- "So you did it. I must admit, I had my doubts that you could make this happen."
- "And I'm not talking to you. It is time." (Gordon)
- "Call in the transport. We're leaving." (Militia Soldier)
- "It is time for the people of Gotham to see their savior for who he truly is. A man. Just a man. Devoid of hope, betrayed by his friends, crippled by fear."
- "You both still have a part to play." (Gordon)
- "Once I understood your greatest fear, controlling you was simple. You blame yourself for her condition."
- "You need to protect her, but buried deep down is the inevitability that you will one day fail."
- "And that fear makes you mine."
- "Think very carefully about your next move, Commissioner. Her life depends on it."
- "Did you think I wanted him dead? Did you think that would save your daughter?" (Gordon)
- "Do you know what happens when a man refuses to be controlled by his fears?" (Gordon)
- "He must face them!" (Gordon)
- "Shh... It's OK to be afraid." (Oracle)
- "Do not listen to Batman's false orders. The Knight is gone. You answer to me and me alone." (To the militia at the clock tower after using the voice synthesizer too much)
- "Do you take pride in what you have reduced them to? The mewling babes your assaults exposed? I will do that to you, Dark Knight. I will peel back every layer of the Batman before the night is through."
- "Gallant police force of Gotham. I have a message for you. You are not safe. You are not protected. Batman will not save you. This is the beginning for the end for you, Dark Knight."
- "GCPD- The home of Gotham's brave men and women, a beacon for hope in a city of chaos and despair. Watch as I obliterate it, and the lives of all that cower within its walls!"
- "Remove them."
- "Barbara Gordon."
- "You cannot sustain their hope any longer, Batman. They will die afraid and forsaken. Reflect on your failure as you salvage their corpses from the rubble."
- "You cannot stop it, Batman. Their world is crumbling."
- "Nothing's changed, sergeant. Reduce that edifice to dust and this battle is ours."
- "The ones that fight at your side still believe in you. I will show them how misplaced that belief is."
- "It's time. Send them in."
- "You played your part. Now Batman will play his."
- "Looking for someone? You should know by now that nowhere is safe. The Commissioner was so eager to betray you earlier, when his daughter's life depended on it. And now, I have your Robin, the caged bird. Fascinating that your fears would drive you to lock your closest ally in a prison cell. Now those same fears will make you do as I say. There's a storage depot in Kingston. Go there, alone. Prepare to take off that mask. Or your friends will die."
- "Your fears got the better of you I see. How fitting that I will win and Batman's life will be over... not because of what I have done to your precious city, but because you are scared of what I will do to your friends, your family. They are your weakness, hiding just below the surface. I'm sure that you're scared of what will happen when I tear that mask from your face. What will we find? Your true identity, or proof that without your mask you are nothing. Impotent. Powerless, Afraid. Leave your equipment on that table, and we can find out."
- "Now, the truck."
- "The die is cast, Batman, and from now on I need your undivided attention. The nightmare is almost over, your failure almost complete. I can see it, and soon the whole world will see it too. Your eyes betray you. You are truly afraid."
- "Are you ready?" (Batman)
- "Enough bravado. It's too late for that. I don't care who you are, but they will. I'm going to rob them of hope. As they stare into your eyes they will blame you...Failure will have a face and a name."
- "It's time."
- "Mister Gordon, I would like you to do the honors." (Gordon)
- "Take off that mask or my next shot will kill him. NOW!" (Gordon)
- "Wayne? Bruce Wayne?"
- "Now the world can see you for what you truly are. A legend laid bare. Powerless. Human. Afraid."
- "Do you know what happens now, Mr. Wayne? I'm not going to kill you... I'm going to set you free... Free to see the city you swore to defend tear itself apart. Free to see everyone you love hunted down and killed. Every scream, every death, vengeance for all that Batman has done."
- "What? Do you not understand? It is over." (Joker is in control of Batman)
- "Do you understand, Gotham?"
- "You have no savior."
- "No more hope... No- more- Batman!"
- "I've won."
- "Without fear, life is meaningless."
- "No!" (before being injected with his own toxin by Batman)
- "AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHH!" (after being injected with his own toxin by Batman and facing his own fears.)
Game Over Lines Edit
- "And at the end of fear, oblivion!"
- "You failed, now suffer!"
- "Now madness takes you, forever!"
- "Didn't you know, Dark Knight, you can't fight fear?"
- "Die, knowing that I will make them suffer, every one."
- "You die here and your legend dies with you."
- "You have failed to stop me Batman, now Gotham will fall."
- "This is the end Dark Knight, you have nothing to be afraid of anymore."
- "I wanted more than your death and Gotham's destruction, but you force my hand." (When leaving a bomb to detonate in Campaign for Disarmament.)
- "Prepare yourself, Batman. My reign of terror starts now."
Batman: Assault on ArkhamEdit
Batman: Arkham AsylumEdit
Batman: Arkham CityEdit
Batman: Arkham KnightEdit
- The Doctors Murphy and Combs that were mentioned in Scarecrow's Patient Interview Tapes referenced Cillian Murphy, who played Scarecrow in the Dark Knight Trilogy, fitting as Batman Begins and The Dark Knight, the two most recent depictions of Scarecrow at the time of Arkham Asylum's release, and Jeffery Combs, the voice of Scarecrow in the fourth season of Batman: The Animated Series.
- Scarecrow's glove in Arkham Asylum resembled the titular bladed glove of Freddy Krueger, the fictional serial killer from the Nightmare on Elm Street films.
- His syringe glove in Arkham Knight, however, more resembled the claws of Wolverine from Marvel, as they were retractable and only notably activated when Scarecrow made a fist.
- Crane needing to make a specific gesture with his fingers could also be a nod to Spider-Man as well; specifically, his web shooters. Spidey could only activate them with just his middle and ring fingers, so they wouldn't go off by accident if he made a fist.
- Scarecrow was the only villain in Arkham Asylum to mention Batman as Wayne. He said his surname during the third encounter. However, as Batman was wildly hallucinating at the time, it was very unlikely that Crane himself actually knew Batman's secret identity, and in Arkham Knight, he was surprised when he found out Batman's identity. Ironically, it would be much later that Scarecrow became the one that finally unmasked Batman and revealed his identity to the world.
- After you defeated Bane, Dr. Kellerman said that "Just after you took the elevator down, the PA was full of screaming. It was horrible." if you returned to the Patient Observation Room to speak to him.
- Scarecrow had his own Challenge Map that was titled "Scarecrow Nightmare." Crane himself appeared in the background, similar to his in-story hallucination appearances, and taunted Batman as he fought the Fear Gas skeleton thugs under his command. The goal was to survive for as long as possible against the never ending waves of thugs without taking a single hit, which instantly killed Batman.
- During the final nightmare with Scarecrow, you could not skip the cutscene with Joker taking Batman to the asylum, which made it the only un-skippable scene in the game.
- Like Joker, Scarecrow didn't have an identifiable cell at Arkham Asylum. Theoretically, he could have been held in the "Extreme Isolation" area of Arkham, which was the one place that the player could not explore.
- In Scarecrow's Lair under the elevators, computer monitors showed security camera images of Batman escorting Joker through Arkham. Crane may have already escaped his cell prior to the riot, and had managed to observe the event. Given the number of supplies that were present, Crane may have had a way of slipping in and out of his cell without being noticed, and smuggled in the necessary items.
- During the nightmare sections of Batman: Arkham Asylum, Batman would occasionally appear as Scarecrow, which made Scarecrow technically a playable character.
- Crane's appearance in Arkham Asylum had been ranked as the 38th Greatest Moment in Gaming.
- The Arkhamverse Scarecrow made a cameo in the DC game, Injustice: Gods Among Us. The game had many damaging stage transitions, one of which took place in the Arkham Asylum Stage. One player could throw another through a wall and into Crane's cell. Scarecrow would inject the player with his Fear Toxin, which triggered a voyage into Crane's nightmare world, before they were thrown into another section of the level.
- Scarecrow is the only villain to physically appear in Arkham Asylum, who doesn't have his face revealed in game.
- His face is revealed in Arkham Knight. Listening to criminals in Gotham reveals that he underwent facial reconstructive surgery, and isn't wearing a mask, meaning his face has been redesigned to look like his trademark mask.
- In Arkham Asylum, Crane's skin was deathly pale and he was extremely skinny, which indicated possible anorexia. Oddly, Crane appeared much taller in Arkham Knight, which was unusual given his crippled state. It should also be noted that during Arkham Asylum, Scarecrow walked hunched over whereas in Arkham Knight, he walked normally. It's possible that the leg brace prevents him from hunching over.
- The injuries Crane sustained from Croc, along with the underwent Surgery would explain the drastic change in his natural voice Between Arkham Asylum & Arkham Knight.
- In his Game Over Lines for Arkham Knight, Scarecrow's voice was always distorted by his Fear Toxin. That was even when he's not actually around when Batman died.
- A barely noticeable outlining of Scarecrow could be seen next to the Azrael symbol at the Church and Medical Center in Arkham City.
- The "City of Terror" code that was required to unlock Crane's Barge was one of the hardest security codes to decrypt in Arkham City, because it was at level five on the Cryptographic Sequencer.
- In the one his the phone calls to Batman in Arkham City, the Joker implied that he was aware that Scarecrow was still alive.
- Scarecrow's Arkham Knight design resembled his incarnation in the 4th season of Batman: The Animated Series. In that season, Scarecrow resembled a legitimate undead being in a preacher's outfit. In both designs, their teeth were visible as well, though while in the former's case, it was his genuine teeth, in the latter it was left ambiguous, as the producers were uncertain if there was someone under the mask. It was revealed by Militia chatter that Scarecrow underwent surgery after he was attacked by Killer Croc to make his face appear as it did in Arkham Knight, which meant it's his actual face in the final game.
- Canisters full of Scarecrow's Fear Gas appeared as Easter Eggs throughout Arkham City, most prominently in the Riddler's third hostage room: an area that was covered with razor wire which could be examined either in first person mode or by a Remote Control Batarang, and also at Hush's Hideout. Upon viewing these specific canisters, if you listened, you could hear strange voices in the room, that were possibly started by the leaking Fear Gas.
- Scarecrow's face in Arkham Knight resembled a mutilated serial killer, rather fitting for a terrorist and criminal. He even considered releasing his Fear Toxin upon the world to be "terrorism in its purist form."
- The fact that Scarecrow chose Halloween Night to attack Gotham further showed his fascination of fear, and why he chose to take advantage of the night that lore had said fear would be at it most powerful, since monsters, like Scarecrows, are said to be at their strongest on Hallow's Eve, which may explain how Scarecrow became more dangerous. But what Scarecrow may have or have not overlooked, is that creatures like Bats (like Batman and the Arkham Knight were modeled after), can draw power from this night as well, which may also explained why they both defeated him in the end. Additionally some of the rioters will comment that Scarecrow must have a sense of humor initiating his plan on Halloween, which is considered to be the scariest night of the year.
- Scarecrow "getting a taste of his own medicine" in Arkham Knight seemed to have been taken from the first movie of the Dark Knight Trilogy, Batman Begins, and the episode "Nothing to Fear" from Batman: The Animated Series. In all three cases, Crane saw Batman as a demonic version of a bat. The only difference was that in Arkham Knight, the dose severely broke him into becoming harmless, while in Batman Begins, it made Scarecrow a lot more dangerous
- From a certain point of view, Scarecrow won his last battle against Batman, as the Dark Knight's identity was revealed to the world, which forced Bruce Wayne to fake his death, though his legend was kept intact. His remark of this night being Batman's last was ultimately correct.
- Scarecrow managing to unveil Bruce Wayne's identity to the people of Gotham and presumably the world gave him the distinction of not only being the only incarnation of Scarecrow to do so, but the only Batman villain in any medium thus far to succeed at that. An impressive feat, in overview.
- The final nightmare that Scarecrow forced the player to experience in Arkham Asylum, specifically that of Batman going insane and the numerous Arkham inmates beginning to run the city, was fulfilled in Arkham Knight fittingly by Scarecrow himself.
- In the Arkham Knight Novelization, Scarecrow was aware that Batman was hallucinating the Joker and revealed to the Dark Knight that he and Joker were working together. Joker contacted Scarecrow after he injected Batman with his blood and Scarecrow modified his Fear Toxin to bring out the Joker in Batman. However, it seems that Crane is unaware when the Joker surfaces in Batman as both times he either thought Batman was just acting different or wasn't afraid despite being injected with fear toxin.
- When Batman was trying to put the canisters in place at Ace Chemicals, Scarecrow's old gas mask from Arkham Asylum could be seen laying on the floor. It could have been symbolic, for the self-destructive streak that Crane exhibited, or the departure from his formerly less serious self.
- It seems that Crane had duplicates of his old mask, given there was one in Knight, and in City. It's quite possible that these masks were his calling cards to Batman.
- In a sense of irony, Scarecrow adopts the kneeling position mentioned in Hugo Strange's rules for Arkham City - "if a TYGER guard approuches you for any reason, you must adopt a kneeling position with your hands behind your head. Failure to do so will be treated as an aggressive response and dealt with with extreme force" - but is hit by Batman regardless.
- Despite Croc being responsible for his mutilation, Scarecrow has never made any attempt to try exacting revenge. It's possible Crane developed a fear of Croc due to the mauling he received from him, or Crane's memory had become so twisted, he may have believed Batman threw him to Croc, like how Joker sometimes suggests Batman threw him in the tank of acid that lead to his transformation.
- Save for Batman and Crane himself, all people that were infected with Scarecrow's new Fear Toxin died. Crane himself was supposed to be immune, but even he was permanently affected by the end of Arkham Knight. That gave an indication as to how strong the new Fear Toxin actually was.
- The official website for Arkham Knight gave an indication that Scarecrow did in fact gain partial immunity to his toxin, presumably from having used it for his whole career. It is possible that his new toxin was strong enough to get past this immunity, however.
- It is also possible that Scarecrow's immunity to the toxin only extended as far as decreasing it's physical lethality, as opposed to nullifying it's psychological effects.
- For some reason, Scarecrow's face and personal attire slightly resembled Ermac's face and personal attire in Mortal Kombat X, mainly due to Ermac's face resembling an zombie as well as usually wearing hooded long robes. In some YouTube video images, they use Ermac instead of Scarecrow.
- In Arkham Asylum, during the cutscene when Scarecrow was seen being taken by Killer Croc during his mauling, his cowl could be seen flying off his face for a split second, which meant that his cowl was not attached to the rag by his chest.
- Some comic book incarnations of Scarecrow show that he was a psychologist, and some show him as a psychiatrist. In Arkham Knight, his bio shows that he is a psychiatrist and not a psychologist. So theoretically, this might be an indication (possibly an oversight or to reveal his true occupation) that with his knowledge of psychology and biochemistry combined, he is a psychiatrist in both the game series and the comics.
- Scarecrow's display case shows that he has a Ph.D. in psychology, but when his bio showed that he is a psychiatrist, it's supposed to be showing that he has a medical degree (M.D.) in psychiatry; this is possibly an oversight as well. To become a psychiatrist, you would need to complete medical school in order to earn an M.D. in the field.